hika_lyra: (Default)
[personal profile] hika_lyra
I've just finished this book about two days ago, I've posted my thoughts in my ig, it was a short kind of review so I decided to make a longer one in my LJ :D

I decided to buy this book because there was a cheap book fair in a family market in my neighbourhood, and when I search in google: "agatha christie famous novels", this books appears in google's most popular first.

And also, this novel comes in first place in this site and this other site

Now I'll start with the review and of course yes, this review contains spoilers...


(The Novel's Cover from Goodreads)

First, I have to acknowledge that Agatha Christie is an extremely clever writer. She is indeed the Queen of Crime. She hid the facts so well yet it was right in front of us, she made the narration so awesome--such a clever first person as a observer point of view story telling and also she gave some subtle words that made our mind indirectly thought that this 'specific person' is a good guy, not a murderer.

The book was pacing slowly and nicely like usual detective stories. The beginning seemed so simple and kinda boring, about a murder of a wealthy man in a small village/countryside. Hearing this plot must have made your mind think of the most cliche motive that is heritage. If you think that heritage is the motive, then you're wrong. But we'll save the motive later, for when you read the book.

We were told the story by a man named Doctor Sheppard, he is the village doctor and since this village is so small, everybody knows everyone and everyone loves to gossip in here, since there were no other interesting things to do. The story starts when a woman named Mrs. Ferrars died. She was Roger Ackroyd's lover. About few days after her death, Ackroyd got a letter from her, saying she was being blackmailed by someone. Before Roger Ackroyd could read the letter, he was killed.

Doctor Sheppard got a phone call saying that Roger Ackroyd was killed, so he rushed to the house and with the help of Parker the butler, they called the police. These police investigations seemed boring and very ordinary. The case looked so ordinary and the suspect is Ackroyd's only step-son, Captain Ralph Paton. Captain Paton soon to be fiancee, Flora Ackroyd seeked after Poirot's help. The story still seemed kinda plain until Poirot's little meeting with all of the suspects. After that, the story begin to climb and it got more and more interesting.

Almost every suspect in this story lied, or you could say that the kept a secret. So Agatha Christie started to told the story from Doctor Sheppard's point of view about each and every one's little secret, until the story reached the murderer's secret--or you could say, the revelation.

Usually, we get Hasting as the narrator of Poirot's stories. I've read 3 Poirot novels (yes, that is not much at all) before this one and I've read it a long time ago so I didn't really remember how Hastings usually told his and Poirot's adventure. Well, in here Doctor Sheppard as the narrator was kinda underestimating Poirot's ability, which is I think people's usual way of thinking when they had just met Poirot (and almost every other detective in general detective novels).

Almost until the last chapter I could not guess the culprit. However, when I gather the clues that Poirot told and stated, I could immidiately guess who is the murderer and it shocked me. Just like the famous Sherlock Holmes said, "when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth." It was quite improbable but yet it was the truth.

So overall I think this novel is a must read novel for mystery/detective stories lovers like me. Goodreads gives 4.18 ratings for this book, I think this novel deserved the score, since the beginnings was a bit boring for me and the culprit's ending was kinda annoying.He commited suicide. (Oh suicide endings, how I detest thee)

But on a second thought, I guess it deserve more than 4.18, like 4.5 or something (or maybe more) since Christie did not hid the fact, the writing was very clever and I think it does not contain any plot holes (and also this novel's ending was very anti-mainstream of course for 1926). Well the indonesian translation that I bought was quite bad, there were kind of a lot of errors and misspelling, I think. Although I bought it between Rp 20.000,00-Rp 30.000,00 that's about $2.00 or $3.00, very cheap indeed. So, the misspelling and errors did not bother me that much, also those errors does not blow the awesome ending, so it's all right.


Well, the end then! Fiuh~ This was quite a long post, with some typos and wrong grammars I believe (since I don't bother to check it again,... #toolazy #sorrynotsoryy). So, I hope someone read this, and I hope you enjoy it. Until next time ~
Anonymous( )Anonymous This account has disabled anonymous posting.
OpenID( )OpenID You can comment on this post while signed in with an account from many other sites, once you have confirmed your email address. Sign in using OpenID.
Account name:
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.


Notice: This account is set to log the IP addresses of everyone who comments.
Links will be displayed as unclickable URLs to help prevent spam.


hika_lyra: (Default)

April 2017

23456 78

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 22nd, 2017 01:38 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios